Impact Leadership Solutions
← All articles

November 17, 2026

Conflict Management for Leaders: What to Do When Two People Can’t Work Together

Learn practical conflict management steps for leaders when two colleagues can’t work together, from identifying the root issue to setting clear expectations and following up.

A man and a woman in a calm, facilitated conversation across a table in a modern executive office

Many leaders wait too long to address tension between two people on their team. There is always a more pressing decision, and stepping into someone else’s relationship can feel like overreach.

The cost of waiting is usually higher than the discomfort of acting. Decisions slow down, other people get drawn into the friction, and work that depends on both people becomes harder to move forward.

Your role is not to decide who has the better personality or to make everyone agree. It is to understand what is happening, address the work and behavior involved, and set a clear standard for how people need to work together.

Conflict is a normal part of working across different priorities, communication styles, and responsibilities. Leaving it unaddressed is what turns a difficult relationship into an ongoing constraint for the team.

Start by Understanding the Conflict

Before bringing the two people together, speak with each of them separately. This gives you a chance to hear what has happened, how each person sees the situation, and what they believe needs to change. It also helps you avoid turning a joint meeting into a debate over who is right.

Ask for specific examples. “We don’t communicate well” is a starting point, not a full account. Find out what was said or done, when it happened, how it affected the work, and whether it has happened before.

Listen for the source beneath the friction. The issue may involve unclear decision rights, competing priorities, missed handoffs, scarce resources, different work styles, or a pattern of disrespectful behavior. These causes call for different responses. A relationship conversation won’t solve an ownership dispute if you still haven’t decided who owns the work.

Use neutral language as you gather information. You might say, “I’ve noticed that the project handoffs are getting delayed. Help me understand what’s happening.”

Coach’s Tip: Ask each person, “What is one recent, specific interaction that shows the problem?” Then ask, “What effect did it have on the work?” Keep your notes focused on observable events, impacts, and follow-up questions, not assumptions about intent.

Check Whether a Joint Conversation Is Appropriate

A facilitated conversation can help when both people are willing to participate and the issue centers on working styles, communication, expectations, or a misunderstanding. It is not the right first step for every dispute.

If someone raises concerns about harassment, discrimination, threats, retaliation, or safety, contact HR and follow your organization’s policies. Don’t try to resolve a serious allegation through informal mediation or ask the people involved to work it out together.

Also consider what the participants need in order to speak candidly. A meaningful conversation requires a clear purpose, enough time, privacy, and confidence that concerns will be heard fairly. If someone feels unable to take part, pause and seek appropriate support.

Coach’s Tip: Before scheduling a joint meeting, check with HR if the concern involves potential misconduct or a policy issue. For other conflicts, ask each person privately whether they’re willing to discuss what needs to change in a facilitated conversation.

Set the Conversation Up to Be Useful

When a joint discussion is appropriate, explain the purpose in advance: to understand the impact of the conflict and agree on workable next steps. Make clear that the goal is not to assign blame or require the people involved to become friends.

Set a few practical ground rules:

  • Speak about specific actions and their impact, not about someone’s character.
  • Let each person finish without interruption.
  • Avoid “always” and “never” statements and return to a specific example.
  • Listen to understand the other person’s account, even when you disagree.
  • Focus on what each person can do differently from here.

Open neutrally. For example: “I want us to understand where the work is breaking down and agree on how you’ll handle the next project handoff.” Give each person time to describe their perspective. Reflect back what you heard without endorsing one account over the other.

This is also the point to distinguish intent from impact. Someone may not have intended to dismiss a colleague, but the impact still needs to be discussed. The standard is not whether a person meant harm. It is whether the behavior supports the working relationship the role requires.

A man and a woman have a focused one-on-one conversation at a small table beside large windows

Coach’s Tip: If the conversation becomes personal, interrupt calmly: “Let’s return to what happened and how it affected the work.” Then invite each person to describe one specific change that would make future interactions more effective.

Look for the Work Problem Behind the Relationship Problem

Some conflicts ease when people understand each other’s perspectives. Others continue because the organization has left important work unclear. If both people believe they own a decision, or neither believes they do, asking them to communicate better won’t resolve the underlying issue.

Make the leadership decisions that may be contributing to the friction. Clarify who makes the decision, who provides input, who completes each task, and how changes are communicated. If priorities conflict, explain which one takes precedence and why. If a handoff keeps failing, define what information needs to be shared and by when.

It can help to frame the question around the work system rather than personal blame: “What in our process is making this handoff unreliable?” That doesn’t remove individual accountability. It helps you see whether clearer roles or a more reliable process is part of the solution.

When the conflict involves repeated behavior, address that directly too. Clear responsibilities don’t excuse disrespect, withheld information, or missed commitments.

Coach’s Tip: At the end of the discussion, ask, “What decision, role, or process is still unclear?” Write down the answer, name who will clarify it, and set a specific next step. Without an owner, the same issue returns as another interpersonal dispute.

Agree on Observable Behaviors

“Work together better” sounds constructive but gives people little to act on. Agreements should describe visible actions that both people can recognize and you can follow up on.

Examples might include:

  • Share changes to a deadline in the project channel by the end of the workday.
  • Raise disagreements directly with the person involved before escalating them to colleagues.
  • Include the designated decision-maker in approval requests.
  • Acknowledge a colleague’s message within the agreed response window, even if a full answer will come later.

Ask each person to state what they will do, not only what they expect the other person to change. Confirm what happens if a commitment can’t be met, and where either person should raise a concern. Keep the agreements brief and document them in line with your organization’s practices.

The expectation is professional cooperation, not personal closeness. People don’t need to agree on everything or choose to spend time together. They do need to meet the conduct and coordination requirements of their roles.

Coach’s Tip: Test every agreement with this question: “Could I tell whether this happened?” If the answer is no, replace the general promise with a specific action, timeframe, or communication channel.

A man and a woman review a document together in a modern open-plan office

Follow Up, Then Decide What Comes Next

A difficult conversation is not the same as a resolution. Check in after an agreed interval, often within a couple of weeks, to see whether the new behaviors are happening and whether the work is moving more reliably. Speak with each person, and, if useful, review the agreement together.

Ask questions tied to the commitments: “Are the handoffs happening when agreed?” “What is working better?” “Where is the process still breaking down?” If a commitment was missed, address it promptly and specifically. If the problem persists despite a clear agreement, consult HR and consider the next appropriate management step.

Sometimes the most workable outcome is a change in responsibilities or workflow rather than a repaired personal relationship. You can adjust how people coordinate while still holding each person accountable for professional conduct. The response should reflect the situation, the organization’s policies, and the needs of the work.

For more on how different approaches to disagreement shape interactions, read Insight Into Conflict: How Different Styles Handle Disagreement. If you’re navigating a persistent team dynamic or a leadership challenge with broader organizational impact, executive coaching can provide a confidential space to examine your options and plan your next conversations.

Coach’s Tip: Put a follow-up date on your calendar before the first conversation ends. At the check-in, review the agreed behaviors and their effect on the work. If the commitments aren’t holding, name the gap and explain the next step calmly and directly.

Conflict management doesn’t require you to remove every difference between two people. It does require you to understand what is driving the tension, clarify what the work needs, and uphold a consistent standard of behavior.

What needs to become clearer for the two people on your team to work together more reliably?

Newsletter

Ideas for your next chapter, in your inbox

Get tips every other week that will help you lead with greater confidence, clarity, and purpose. No noise, and you can leave at any time.

About the newsletter →